Stephanie Kate Strohm / Noor Sofi
Adapted from the book by Stephanie Kate Strohm (2024)
(Not a review, just some notes to help me remember the things I've read. But written this way because it's the Internet, and some people will stumble across this page.)
This past fall, I started looking for more standalone graphic novels at the library, both to read and to find examples of artwork that I could show in my Graphic Novel class. This was one that caught my eye. I saw that it was a Twisted Tale (although I was sure what that meant at the time). Only recently did I notice that it was adapted from an earlier book.
It's funny that Disney now owns Marvel, and Marvel created the comic "What if...?" because this starts off like a "What if" book, but this doesn't carry that title.
A quick check on the original book shows me that Stephanie Kate Strohm is known for reimagining Disney classics, not just only books and fairy tales. The reason I was curious about this is that I wanted to know when it because a Disney product, if it had been designed that way. There are points in the story where I wonder if they were inspired by the original nvoel or by the stage show (which I may have seen once, but I'm familiar with some of the music).
In this story, Peter Pan never flew to Wendy's house to find his shadow. Wendy and the boys grew up a bit. During that time, Wendy was still telling stories about Neverland, which she's dreamed of even if she's never visited. Angry that Peter never came, Wendy makes a deal with Captain Hook -- she trades him Peter's shadow in exchange for passage. It's a trap, of course, but a friendly pirate sets her free.
Neverland isn't what she thought it was, and neither are the Lost Boys who have a Lost Girl (or Lost Person) among them.
Wendy learns that Tinkerbell kept Peter away from her because she was jealous. Tinkerbell takes a piece of Wendy's voice so that she can speak (although the other fairies don't seem to have a problem...), and the two becomes friends. They set off to find and rescue Peter, who is searching in dangerous places for his shadow. Meanwhile, Hook plans to use the shadow to destroy Neverland.
Wendy learns that her stories have the power to shape Neverland, but so do many other children who dream about it. She also learns that the best way to save Neverland is to try to reshape her own world, even if she is a woman. (In the epilogue, there's almost a nod to Mary Poppins as the narrative jumps ahead even more years so that she can be a suffrogette.
It was an enjoable book for what it is, and it was a quick read. I managed to complete it in a couple of train rides. Meanwhile, it's been sitting next to the bed for probably three or four months. It only came out a year and a half ago. There isn't much demand for it, assuming people know about it. In any case, it's back on the shelves.
I have a couple more graphic novels and manga from the library to get to and even more in my classroom.
If you stumbled across my page via the Internet, please check out my short book series, Burke Lore Briefs. A fantastical foursome of flash fiction and short stories.
